The Archive for Religion & Cognition

Jump to ARC number:    

ARC number: 2

(Technical Id number: 3)

Author(s): Lisdorf, Anders
Title: The conflict over Cicero's house: an analysis of the ritual element in De Domo Sua
Category: published article
Length (pages):
Keywords: ritual; Roman religion
 
Abstract: According to the Romans themselves ritual was at the heart of their culture.
Strangely, this centrality of ritual has not been matched by a corresponding sensitivity
to how ritual was to be interpreted. Ritual has most often been viewed as
an empty formalism devoid of any true belief. It is argued in this article that this
view of ritual is an ethnocentric construct stemming from a Christian conception
of belief, which does not adequately account for the peculiarities of ritual based
religions. Taking the seemingly obscure and little studied case of the conflict
over Cicero’s house as a case, it is argued that E. Thomas Lawson’s and Robert
N. McCauley’s ritual theory might help to overcome this misconception of ritual.
This enables us to see how Cicero explicates implicit beliefs entailed by the ritual
actions. Ultimately the evidence seems to support the reverse interpretation:
that ritual was taken very seriously.
 
Remarks:
 
Email: anersl @ hum.ku.dk
Bibliography: Lisdorf, A. 2005: "The conflict over Cicero's house: An analysis of the ritual element in 'De Domo Sua'", Numen-International Review for the History of Religions, nr. 52: 445-464
URL: http://www.springerlink.com/content/j1317p372j211572/fulltext.pdf
Downloadable files:
 
Submitted:13/11/2006 09:04:20    (DD / MM / YYYY)
Published:14/11/2006 12:39:10    (DD / MM / YYYY)

Jump to ARC number: